I don't like Shadoweh. The drunk on ego GreyICE attitude is not something I've seen her do before, and not only does that mean that she's calling out on everybody else for sucking at the game, she's also giving herself merits for consolidation that don't really apply.
She started pushing the Raikaria wagon in her
#129 which was around when half the day had gone by, CF7 claimed and Raikaria was at two votes. The only wagon waffling that happened after CF7's claim scattering the wagon was when Rai was left at L-2 or L-1 and claimed doc, then people scattered again to try to lynch Mitsuki/Shadoweh/Conq instead. Shadoweh wasn't around for that period of time when it was crucial to get people back on a big wagon to get a lynch for the day.
So no, Shadoweh didn't do anything special. Honestly, if you can't get your scumread lynched over an actual case that you're pushing for and that convinces other people to join the wagon in other ways that aren't pressuring with "VOTE X OR YOU'RE A RETARD", I'm pretty sure the game is better off without this kind of pushing around. My whole issue with this is that it's very convenient for scum to play "town leader" like this to push hard for lynches under the pretense of getting their scumread lynched and be able to put out minimal content this way. All there is to Shadoweh's name other than the Raikaria push are a bunch of seemingly arbitrary townreads with no explanation to them.
She could be seen as town with what I said I guess, but I'm just really gutting hard scum on the responses to the tunneling accusations going "no I did good it's just that you suck so I have to do it for you". I'd burn it.
NNR had a thing in mid-D1 interactions with several people where he wasn't scumhunting at all and just seemed to be calling out bad arguments from other cases and why they were bad. It felt like the "no town you're doing it wrong" posts that are tempting to make as scum since you're technically being helpful to town and it looks like you're doing something (which is part of the reason I gut scum on Shadoweh's latest posts now that I managed to put that into words). But later on he evolved into blatant rolefishing at Mitsuki's rolerelated Zak shenanigans which he always seems to do as town (I imagine he would attempt to avoid it as scum) and seems to be pursuing his cases in his typical fashion of hypocrisy and other things that imo are pretty bad as scumtells which points quite a bit at town!NNR. I think I'd put him somewhere in between BT and Conq in my earlier townread section.
CF7 presence felt like it died down a lot once the wagon scattered after the claim, which feels like a scum move, but when I checked his ISO real quick he did actually post quite a few times after that, just with really little content, which kind of resembles the small posts before he became a main wagon. The scattered claim thing seemed too odd for scum to do and role is proven, but I don't think that the role alone makes him auto-town, I could see the role being part of a scumrole as a handicap. And... not much else to say from memory really, I need a reread on him.
Actually I think pretty much everyone else is people who I haven't given much scrutiny in my first readthrough (Serela, Validon, SB, Dan, Zak and ninja) so I think I'll just stop here to go get lunch and reread when I get back. I start lessons in two hours though so I might not be able to write up another post before I go.
