Well damn. I kind of blame myself for this loss. Not only was I pretty much fucking insane after D1, but had dealt with one more day with replacing out, I would have likely switched to Chitose mid-day, which may have given new!Monoe (were you Kiro?) the cred he needed to not die horribly from all my D1-D3 slipups. However, I think the biggest factor in our loss overall was simply the majority of town (Moon, Prinny, Kyon, Anon, and so on) tripping over itself, while scum stayed in the background played solidly enough to avoid suspicion. Ah well.
Aside from that, I'm eager to see how the guesses worked out, since I felt a lot of players (including myself) were obvious this game, which probably means they actually weren't and I was wrong. Oh boy.
Also, Kilga, it'd be neat if you posted the sources for all the role names (or at least it would be in my opinions, as I am a fan of quirky role names). Curly Brace was pretty obvious, and I was under the impression that the Unstopping Believer could talk at night as a result of taking the midnight train going anywhere, but I had no real guess for most of the others (if they were even intended as obscure references).