It's a little hard to follow post numbers when you don't include links.
To answer all your questions for me:
The reason I brought up CATS is because CATS, while town, wasn't a very good player, and many players hardly considered him the "only confirmed townie". Since it was an off-night for CATS, I found the NK strange to say the least. Protoman is far more dangerous to scum than CATS.
Basically, I think players that think Protoman is less confirmed town (or an easier target) than CATS are more likely to be scum than players who think Protoman is a far greater asset to town than CATS.
I summarized all of the times the Comedian used your name. Commedian was never supportive of you, but he pretty much only brought you up to make cases on Kyon:
post 72post 108post 331post 383post 397post 496post 693Anyway, for someone so concerned about role speculation, you sure seem to consider my role inconsequential. But to put it simply: I claimed that I didn't roleblock CATS because I'm the town insomniac, and hence not a roleblocker. It's not scummy at all to make a case on me because of my actions, but any case you do make should have a rebuttal to that point if you want it to remain logically consistent, like Mai, Crocker, and Protoman's rebuttals. It was only after Protoman suggested that I may be third party that you decided I was a survivor.
Kilga: If John Cage is indeed a Survivor, please tell me you have been referring to this game as the John 3:16 setup.
Well, that explains the "Unstopping Believer" flavor.