John Cage here with the evening analysis.
First and foremost, Chitose's role did not sound like it blocked roles to me. I bring this up mostly because I don't want to be quick lynched before anyone remembers that I already claimed Unstopping Believer, which lets me talk at night.
I went back and re-read all of Chitose's posts concerning the Comedian, prior to day 5.
She follows a pattern of attacking Kyon for Kyon's attacks on the Comedian, while saying the Comedian is vaguely suspicious and that she'll get to the Comedian later. Not once does Chitose defend the Comedian, nor does she ever say the Comedian reads town.
I then read through her posts looking for all the times she talked about Crocker and Monoe. The most fascinating thing I find about her case on Crocker is that it went from this:
Crocker and CATS are too boring.
To this.and she did it in the span of one post. Mind you, a lot of things have happened in that time frame, including Crocker's cases on both the Comedian and Chitose; but it's still an interesting 180. This is probably obvious, but town's unanimous decision to lynch Chitose means that she was bussed. Hard.
I went back to reread Monoe's posts, in connection with Chitose and The Comedian. The Comedian was always a high town pick for old Monoe before she disappeared, with
Chitose fairly far down the list on day 3, however, Chtiose's scummyness was also fairly based on
a Kyon scum flip.I mostly did this for Monoe because some of the things he and Chitose said on day 5 bothered me, the more I looked back on them; namely how Monoe was Chitose's third choice for a lynch (the Comedian used a similar strategy, voicing his opinion that if anonymous flipped town, we should lynch Protoman and myself, with Chitose a likely third scum), and how it was Monoe who first said that a Chitose scum flip made me look much worse than Crocker. Yesterday Chitose tried very hard to make it clear that she thought I was derp town, in spite of being bussed. And I have already voiced my Crocker/Chitose suspicions.
Back to Crocker:
And if Chitose flips scum, do you see us as a scumteam and why?
Yes I still can see you two as a scum team because a unanimous decision means Chitose was bussed. I know I'm town, and I found it really strange how neither of you went after me when both of you thought my arguments from last night were weak. I found Chitose's arguments strange since they completely disgarded my own, and because of earlier posts like
this and
this where you told us about every living lurker and scummy player
except, quite conspicuously, Chitose, the Comedian, and maybe Combo Breaker for the day 2 post, but no one was talking about him anyway. What isn't said can often be as scummy as what is said. Neglecting to mention Chitose in those types of "analysis" is especially aparent, because Chitose hasn't exactly been a clean looking player.
