Protoman knows you love quote walls. Sorry, but since Protoman still has lots of questions this is how it has to be.
Protoman is lazy, but whatever, that's the best I'll get and Mai is more or less right about things. I got off track.
Protoman dislikes your assertations that asking you to read yourself and pick what you defend against personally is 'lazy'. What you choose to look at is just as important as what you don't. Telling you exactly what points are important would be detrimental to what Protoman wants from you.
Anyway, first thing. Post 137. What? No, seriously, what? I don't understand your point at all. First, I'm saying that post restricted players should NOT claim. Are you telling me that telling someone to NOT claim is a "subtle rolefish"? I'm...just...please, clarify this.
Bringing up the WIFOM in the first place is a subtle rolefish. Mentioning the topic brings it to people's minds and makes them more likely to talk about their post restrictions, in the same way that putting someone to L-1 and telling them in big bold letters not to hammer has never stopped anyone from hammering before.
Post 159: Already admitted that was a bad hop. But, I figure it's kind of obvious I was voting Prinny for his persistent uselessness and I was voicing general agreement for Sailor Moon's case.
It wasn't obvious. You never named a player before now.
Can you clarify what parts of Sailor Moon's case you agreed with in particular?Now for Sailor Moon. Sailor Moon's initial post D2 was awful. I probably shouldn't have said "Mai was convincing me" so much as just gone with, as I'm pretty sure I said back then, Sailor Moon's D2 post being awful because it was hypocritical. I wanted Mai to restate her case to see what D1 stuff would support my changing read from her point of view.
I'm pretty sure you didn't. Not when you actually voted for her. You mentioned it earlier
here When you wanted both Light and Kyon, in that order, dead more. You never gave a reason that you thought Sailor Moon had become scummier then Light or Kyon. You assert that you still want Light and Kyon dead, and Anonymous dead a little, but feel Sailor Moon's lynch will give more information. So basically, you think other people are scummier but you voted for her anyways when you weren't convinced she was scum.
Please explain how this is a pro-town thought process.
Now, to the uselessness point. Explain how that's scummy when I clearly suspected both of them of being scum?
Because being useless isn't a scum trait and isn't a reason to pick one over the other. It makes you sound like you're prioritizing your lynches for the wrong reasons.
Now as for Gumshoe's post. PRETTY sure I just liked it because it echoed my earlier thought process, which, IIRC, had not been changed regarding Sailor Moon's D1. Honestly, I STILL wasn't sure of Sailor scum until later in the day, I just could see where it was possible. "beginning to see" is not the same as "needs to die now"
Your original thought process was 'frustrated townie' right?
Can you explain how that changed? As I've pointed out above, you never really addressed this. Her hypocriticalness obviously wasn't enough, and her post came off as VERY frustrated and as flailing derp. You can hold this same point against me but the question still stands towards you.
As for Mai, I stand by her being obvious town D1 and still being obvious town. And supposing that she should be a "mislynch target"...HOW DOES THIS MAKE ME SCUM? What POSSIBLE fucking scum intent could you POSSIBLY be bullshitting from that post?
The part where you said Kyon sounded like he was telling his partner not to link to him then put him at L-1? You slipped from your Mai obvtown read at a very inconvenient moment.
How do you think you would have followed up on this the next day if at that moment Kyon paniced and hammered himself?I don't see anything else to answer for in this "case". Anyway, elaborate on the case CATS "stole", please. I might have missed this. May I ask how it should have been so obvious to me? I do not have a perfect memory. In fact, my mafia memory is VERY susceptable to getting skewed and having holes in it.
I will quote for you the relevant part because it's blatantly obvious.
I is reading Gumshoe is case on Chitose, and i are having enjoy it. I will loving add: in post 250, Chitose is parrot of Monoe Post 210 in case against Kyon and acknoledging such. Disregards Kyon case is due to Kyon vote Light. Rest of posting is defend only. Only real next post is 329. In post, She is make excuse unvote light, and vote is Mai for disagree with vote style.
Keep in mind CATS hadn't mentioned Chitose at all before now. You seemed to think this was original and good when you read it,
can you go back to this post and tell me if you still feel the same way?OH! I love Protoman's parting order of lynches. Wasn't I scummy for deflecting things off CATS? But if CATS is potentially not scum, doesn't part of your house of cards start collapsing? How very INTERESTING indeed!
Not really. If CATS isn't scum and you agreed with his case without properly reading it, it could just mean you were buddying up to another town's case, which has been your modus operandi all game. CATS being possible scum is the only read I have explicitly stated might not be correct and my cases on all three of my major suspects were built with that in mind.
Honestly, I think you built this big rickety house of cards with the presumption that John Cage was scum, and were desperately trying to support it. I don't know WHY you would DO this though. There's very little that can be granted as objectively (or even subjectively) scummy in it. Happy?
Obviously it's because I hate you for agreeing with me so much. Since you choose not to answer the original questions I posed in my case, I will repost them for you now.
Anonymous' opening for this day makes me feel a little better about him. I also agree that his push for posts, particularly after posting his own case, was good. The only issue I have is he's only stating one strong opinion. I'd like to hear a wider spread of suspects, as soon as possible.
Why did Anonymous's case that sounded like a ragepost on CATS make you feel better about Anonymous?And finally, Light is working VERY HARD to discredit NK analysis. Given how odd a kill Whim was (I personally would have killed Chitose, Mai, or Protoman), I think there's merit in it, though I think it'd be better to wait for a scum flip to go for it. Light's response was more or less trying to say it'd be useless all around. You seem nervous, Light~
One of these names is not like the other. Mai has been obvious mislynch material since Early Day 1 for using an intuition based scumhunting technique combined with excessive tunneling and not properly explaining her reads. You should have realized this. Why on earth would you think Mai was going to get killed Night 1?I have a third question, in retrospect after re-reading your interactions with Light when he unvoted. Considering what I have pointed out about how terrible your
push to convince him to revote was,
do you or do you not think his unvote and refusal to revote was a pro-town action and why?