All right, starting from post 216, I agree I'm not a fan of anonymous, he is, in fact, one of my null reads. This could change easily. Monoe, in my night post, I think I echoed Protoman about the fact that Gumshoe was flinging dirt at Mai for potentially being "too town to be town". This could easily have been derp, but it's notable.
Anonymous' opening for this day makes me feel a little better about him. I also agree that his push for posts, particularly after posting his own case, was good. The only issue I have is he's only stating one strong opinion. I'd like to hear a wider spread of suspects, as soon as possible.
Sailor Moon, fun fact. There's a post before his pressure one, that actually outlines a case on someone. Granted, it's one person but...it's better than you've started the day with, even if that's not really your "post". If you were truly concerned with giving a strong opening, was there no reason that little blurb could not have found it's way into a more comprehensive post?
Mai is beginning to convince me of this on Sailor Moon. But I *really* don't want to drop Kyon or Light.
Light: That's nice, but what about the other cases that Moon proposed? There were at least three I could count, even though they made up about 25% of her post combined. What was bad about those?
I also enjoy your reporter style analysis of Crocker, and then your "Why not THAT guy?" against myself. I'll tell you why not THAT guy. You've actually been posting and not producing anything of use. C-C-C-COMBO BREAKER appears to be busy, possibly to the point of being replaced. I.e., active lurking, at least at this stage, is far worse than lurking.
Eh, why the hell not.
##Unvote, Vote Light YagamiLight 231: Show not tell. I'd love to see a link to this supposed behavior.
Kyon 233: Ah, thank you, I never was able to figure out why you voted Protoman. And, I can't say I'm impressed. A chainsaw defense is NULL until one of the parties flips. You don't use associative tells to implicate someone without flips. So, yes, your vote came off as OMGUSy with bad reasoning. I still have no issues with The Comedian. Mm, not sure how I feel about your Prinny/SM reasoning. I'm going to *have* to give you a pass on Prinny since I was thinking the same thing about him being useless. Your SM thing bugs me because the wagon on her looked to me more like a perfect case of opportunism on a bad player, something MotK is known for.
Kyon! Thoughts on people who aren't as likely to get lynched today? Rather, people you think are scum that currently aren't being pushed a lot. It's easy to implicate both Moon and Light. Do some actual work.
Light 235: OK, Sailor did some associative telling, and badly.
What about Kyon and Gumshoe who did the same D1? Kyon connected Mai and Proto. Gumshoe connected Mai and Kyon. Sooooo?
I was originally going to yell at John Cage for wasting his night talk, but then some stuff that looks good before the game started.
First, what do you mean wasting? And second, the second part of that sentence has syntax issues.
Kyon 237: If I started to look bad and then got better, perhaps you're looking for the wrong intent. Not sure how I feel about the fencesit on Comedian.
Kyon 241: Not enough information yet to draw conclusions from the Whim kill. I...THINK I like the fact you're trying though. I'd say let it rest until we have at least one flipped scum.
Light:
BIGREDX.JPG
Your post suddenly makes me want to look more at the Whim kill. You feel like you're trying to trivialize the concept of analyzing the kill, as opposed to rationally disagreeing with it. Secondly, you're completely wrong about active lurking, particularly when it's the *only thing you've done*
Echoing Protoman's desire for Mai to restate her case. ...AND Protoman's desire for Kyon and Light to get more into who's scum.
Gumshoe's post rubs me the wrong way. Particularly that last town/town comment. Particularly with the soft language that actually just says "Well, Kyon/Light could be town/town, town/scum, or scum/scum, but I'm going to go with whichever one is fact to refer back to when someone flips." I also detect misrep of at least Chitose, and potentially Mai. Not getting good vibes from you.
OK. Gumshoe 258 makes me feel a lot better since it's basically saying the same reasons I found Sailor Moon town.
Mai, do you have any other scum intended posts from Mai? You said you had a case on D1.
All right, caught up, will post my conclusions in a more readable format, though not much has changed.