Well, first, I'm courting headache mode again which isn't a good thing, but I'll try my best to catch up from my last post including Gumshoe's case on Chitose. Hmm...reading it, it's not half bad though I can see at least two things that are wrong, because the flow was actually about what I'd expect. I'll let Chitose defend.
Comedian is wrong about reads without reasoning, but I don't think it makes him scum.
Chitose, what are your current thoughts on Moon? I might have missed them
Monoe, am I correct in concluding you want a Moon lynch over a Light lynch? Because...honestly, I'm pretty swayed by your words and agree a lot of good information can be drawn from her lynch, and that she has a higher than average chance of being scum. I admit I skimmed your post in my previous reply. I still feel Light is scum and I do want to echo Crocker's question about where all his "cases" are.
Kyon 300: Why is Light a better lynch than Sailor Moon given what Monoe has said?
Sailor Moon's post makes her lynch an even more interesting prospect. In fact, it makes a lot of things more interesting prospects. It also renews the value of a Light lynch.
Crocker: What do you think of the information value of a Moon lynch over a Light one? Moon is likely to flip scum, I think.
Actually, Anon, why are you doing the exact same thing Moon did by ignoring a reasonable request? While she might look bad, I still wouldn't mind seeing actual cases on at least three people to see where you stand. You have Moon, at least, but who else is scum? Everything else is just vague and almost reportery.
Protoman, you believe Sailor Moon to be town?
Comedian, actually, there's another reason for reads without reasoning, usually reaction fishing. And that can be a VALUABLE town tool.
Anon has a point about S/M's lack of vote after so firmly declaring Anon scum
Light's 319: Oh, hey, actual content mostly defending himself. I'll give you at least partial credit on Moon's post, Not sure how I feel about your example seeing as it's really the only one you can point to, and finally, the NK analysis point is a fallacy because while there ARE a lot of explanations, you can pare things down by applying logic to it. NK analysis isn't useless, especially when the general attitude is WIFOM. But, again, I'm dropping this til we have a scum flip.
CATS, what about Sailor Moon's behavior today? Are you planning to read the day more in depth? Because this is kind of getting to be too little too late.
Mm, pretty sure Chitose is misrepping Mai, but I'm not certain. It'd be better to let Mai prove her wrong anyway.
The partner shit on page 12 confuses the hell out of me.
Why vote CATS when you seem to be strongly saying Sailor Moon is scum, Protoman?
ALL RIGHT! Caught up and going to totally vote Sailor Moon now
##Unvote, Vote Sailor Moon
I still want Light dead, I kind of want Kyon dead, I think Anonymous dying wouldn't be a bad thing...probably same with CATS. But, I feel Sailor Moon is at the least going to give us the most information regardless of alignment, and is probably scum as well.