Reimu: That's fine, but it seems like that's your only reason, and I don't get why you're sticking with your vote until the end of the day with a case that's based off of one vote from someone's first post in the game. I guess you're gone until D2, but I'd like to hear why you thought that Yamame's vote for Satori made her a better lynch than anyone else today.
It was a combination of that and not really liking any of the other cases made during the day; I thought my point on Yamame taking a convenient stab at Satori was scummier than anything anyone else did, no more and no less. The fact that she wasn't voting Kisume makes her look better D2, so she's not really worth of pursuit at the moment.
Reimu Hakurei:Her reasoning on Yamame is okay, but... just "okay". It was fine during ED1, but at the end of the day I really felt it wasn't anything worth blaming someone over, which she did with her last post. Exaggerates the bad points on Yamame's case a little bit beyond truth ("case could have been applied to anyone", which wasn't necessarily true) and attacks an ED1 case for not having substantial evidence. IMO, her Yamame case was okay when it was ED1 and completely empty when she kept supporting it at the end of the day. Cheerleads the Kisume case because "I don't care if she's town or scum but her train should be informationally valuble." No skin of her back if Kisume flips town, then.
If I was more comfortable with Kisume's lynch, I would have voted her. But when I made my last post D1, Kisume was at L-2 and there was very little real chance of me swinging a significant number of town to my preferred lynch. I stated my acceptance of the Kisume lynch because in lieu of someone I thought had the best chance of being scum, an informational lynch would be better than just shooting blankly into the dark. Calling that "cheerleading" is hardly fair, and frankly looks like you're trying to deflect attention away from yourself, given you were very supportive of the Kisume lynch yourself.
Other thoughts:
-Marisa looks terrible, but I don't see her as scummy at the moment. In a game that requires only a majority to lynch, it makes no sense for scum to stick their neck out by planting a useless vote on a townie.
-Orin looks worse than Marisa, and I'm pretty sure she was past her modkill time before D1 ended if I'm reading timestamps correctly, which makes me wonder why she hasn't been killed yet. If she manages to get in here before she is killed, she has a lot of explaining to do.
Now, since the chances are quite high that the Kisume lynch was at least partially scum-motivated, let's look at everyone that voted her D1. Marisa I covered earlier, and I don't feel she's worth pursuing as scum at this point in time. Parsee is dead. That leaves Utsuho, Sanae, Koishi, and Suwako.
-Suwako I have a bad gut feeling about, but that's mostly because they're obviously an experienced player and gut means little past D1. She hasn't posted much, but what she has posted seems solid enough. Her vote on Kisume doesn't seem overly opportunistic, either, which means it might have been genuine scumhunting.
-Koishi seems a little flaky, and seems to be deflecting as noted in my paragraph above. I'll need to do a bigger reread on her. Her position in the Kisume lynch appears to be in the "safe vote" range for scum, as well.
-I'm running out of time to do a detailed read on Utsuho and Sanae. It'll have to wait until I return this evening.
Right now, I'm leaning Koishi as the scum in that vote lineup, but I'm being herded out the door as we speak. Will have more analysis and a vote as soon as I can.
