Okay, here's the REAL list. I took my time this time, and I wasn't in any mood to spite anyone. The ones from 1-39 I consider in my top tier. Please forgive the fact that I don't only like characters from SA and UFO, and that I like SaBND more than most do.
1 Reimu Hakurei
1 Marisa Kirisame
3 Star Sapphire
4 Yukari Yakumo
5 Fujiwara no Mokou
5 Aya Shameimaru
5 Yuka Kazami
5 Nitori Kawashiro
9 Shikieiki Yamaxanadu
10 Yuyuko Saigyouji
10 Ran Yakumo
12 Cirno
12 Hong Meiling
14 Remilia Scarlet
14 Flandre Scarlet
14 Alice Margatroid
14 Suika Ibuki
18 Sakuya Izayoi
18 Chen
18 Youmu Konpaku
21 Lily White
22 Byakuren Hijiri
23 Mima
23 Yumemi Okazaki
25 Sunny Milk
26 Daiyousei
27 Nue Houjuu
28 Patchouli Knowledge
28 Merlin Prismriver
30 Yuki
30 Shinki
32 Ruukoto
32 Yuka (PC-98)
34 Suwako Moriya
34 Yuugi Hoshiguma
34 Nazrin
37 Tenshi Hinanawi
37 Yamame Kurodani
39 Ichirin Kumoi
39 Unzan
39 Minamitsu Murasa
39 Shou Toramaru
39 Genjii
44 Luna Child
45 Kisume
46 Mystia Lorelei
46 Tewi Inaba
46 Kaguya Hoiraisan
49 Medicine Melancholy
49 Minoriko Aki
49 Hina Kagiyama
49 Sanae Kochiya
49 Kanako Yasaka
49 Iku Nagae
55 Parsee Mizuhashi
55 Ellen
55 Kana Anaberal
55 Rikako Asakura
55 Mugetu
55 Gengetu
61 Koakuma
61 Lyrica Prismriver
63 Rika
63 Marisa Kirisame (PC-98)
63 Luize
66 Chiyuri Kitashirakawa
66 Elly
66 Mai
69 Satori Komeiji
70 Keine Kamishirasawa
71 Letty Whiterock
71 Alice
73 Wriggle Nightbug
74 Rumia
75 Yumeko
76 Hieda no Akyu
77 Rain Fairy
78 Orange
78 Lily Black
80 Tokiko
80 Maribel Hearn
80 Renko Usami
83 Reimu Hakurei (PC-98)
84 Orin (Cat form)
84 Elis
84 Kikuri
87 Kimo-Keine
88 Momiji Inubashiri
89 Utsuho Reiuji (Okuu)
89 Koishi Komeiji
91 Giant Toad
92 Lunasa Prismriver
93 Komachi Onozuka
94 Shizuha Aki
95 Zombie Fairy
96 Kogasa Tatara
97 Great Catfish
98 Eirin Yagokoro
99 Reisen Udongein Inaba
100 Goliath Doll
100 Reisen
102 Shanghai Doll
102 Hourai Doll
104 Rin Kaenbyou (Orin)
104 Watatsuki no Yorihime
106 Edo Explosive Pawn
107 Watatsuki no Toyohime
108 Kotohime
108 Sara
110 Mimi-chan
111 Scarled Devil Mansion Maid
112 Eientei Rabbit
113 Kurumi
114 Leila Prismriver
114 Youki Konpaku
116 Fluff Ball
117 Rinnosuke Morichika
118 Konngara
119 Mr. Kirisame
120 Sariel
121 Yin-Yang Orb
121 Shingyoku
121 YuugenMagan
124 Sake Insect
124 Tsuchinoko
124 Great Tengu of Miyama
127 Meira
I love them all, really. Except for the last seven. Shingyoku's boring, YuugenMagan and Yin-Yang Orb aren't really humanoid, Sake Insect is an insect, Tsuchinoko is a snake thing, Meira is a selfish samurai bitch who's too hard for a stage 2 boss, and I could give a rat's ass about the Great Tengu. I hope there aren't any diehard fans of those characters. I rated Giant Toad higher, because the people love Giant Toad.
Edit: oh god I'm sorry about Koishi, I could have sworn I put her as tied with Satori.