Alright, player-by-player analysis coming up. Given that I managed to completely and utterly miss the Freshers' Fayre and am therefore a member of zero (0) clubs, I can afford to spend some time with this game. I'll try to tl;dr the notable players when I get the chance.
UK - again, the first thing that comes to mind when I think of UK is her 'Vote Anthony for being jumpy oh wait he's just a noob unvote'. The clear was iffy, and the failing to do anything with the vote afterward for a long time is also bad. Had the 'I don't read your walls' fight with Kilga, but since Kilga turned up Town I'm not sure if I can see any relevance in it.
Still, she chose VgT at just the time when the Suwako lynch had tied with it, so being the swing vote there makes me unkeen to suspect her unless the conspiracy theories turn out to be right and Suwako's scum after all. Getting a Town read for now.
Nietz - Goes for Pesco D1 for hanging back, and eventually pulls another vote on VgT. Argued for Anthony's lynch on D2, admitting his Pesco case had come apart a little, but still seems awkward of him. Mild town read based on the VgT vote, and there's not much else to suspect him of right now.
Kiro - Was on VgT the whole day, then attacked Anthony. Hasn't really done anything to make him worth suspecting, to be honest. Town read.
Sodiphas - Another very early jumper on VgT, who quit afterward and therefore would've had no time to move the vote onto say Suwako. I'm feeling really bad about missing that one, to be honest. >_> Town read in retrospect, but Sodium needs to pick up in terms of activity today.
K4U - Goes for Anthony to start, but evens up the Suwako/VgT lynch later on. Goes back to Anthony D2, listing me and him as scum. I'm not sure if the subsequent tunneling of sorts on me is my fault or not for arguing the point so fervently, so I'll call it a nulltell for now. Another slight Town read.
Serp - I can't say much about Serp besides that he's really done nothing to improve his position from D2. His insistence on attacking Suwako well after the clear had been more or less explained is bad, and the positioning on said wagon is also awkward. Scum read.
Pesco - I very, very desperately want to be suspicious of Pesco for nagging at the smallest points he can find in several instances, but given that he was the vote that basically put VgT noticably ahead of the wagons on Anthony, me and himself, it's difficult to criticise him.
Affinity - Day 1 opens with an attack on Umu for pressing me, which is meh since that's about the only way cases will start up. Moves onto Kitten, then Suwako, making one point about VgT and never mentioning him again. This is especially odd since Affinity claims in said post that he
doesn't appreciate VgT's tone or play.On the opening of D2 he immediately links Anthony to VgT. 278 confuses me:
Well, yes, weak case is scum, at least at the beginning of the day.
1. This was a point that Eliphas had made against him the day before which no-one had really followed up on. Why was he compelled to produce a defense against it?
2. The point itself is flawed from what I see. All starting cases are weak by definition because they have nothing solid to work with, so pointing the finger at the first person who tries to say something useful is pretty poor for Town.
378 has him trying to clear Serp to me despite the fact I wasn't even voting him at that point. I'm getting very convinced that the Serp/Affinity scumpair is going on here.
Suwako - The clear has already been explained by Kilga, and my only theory otherwise was a Kilga/Suwako scumpair with the biggest case of Appeal to Authority I've ever seen. Since Kilga's flipped Town, though, I can be more confident in Suwako's affiliation now.
So yeah, that's my wall. tl;dr version following shortly.
