D1 lynches are less about being informed and more about being informative. All you have to go on for a D1 lynch is :words:. Some people are good at :words:, other people not so much.
Once you hit D2, you have a wagon and two flips to look at, and no amount of :words: can change those things. Unless you're Scum Serpentarius and the entirety of town has a collective aneurysm.