Short ver.:
Dan is most certainly not scum since he would've had to lead the BBM bus. The bus on BBM. Also the JoaT. Not impossible but may as well be.
Polly is most certainly
not scum since his role suddenly makes the epitome of sense and he has a similar BBM connection to Dan in that he could have ignored Dan's gut case on D3 but essentially turned it into a wagon by jumping on it for no reason.
Shadoweh doesn't get the same privelege because the BBM wagon was already defined at the time and all she had to do was go "BBM is obviously scum" and jump on. It was her first real mention of him to boot. It was the only other wagon that would work and a vote on me or someone else probably would've been a lot more risky at that time. When BBM claims she gives the "leave it alive" plan a silent OK without ever really solidifying a real opinion on THE CLAIM and at one point literally just asks the confirmed town. BBM himself drops Shadoweh the instance it's established she's "trying more" and never mentions her again in scumteam guesses or vig choices.
But if all that isn't your cup of tea, she practically gave herself away by rolespeccing too hard:
One of them is probably a strongman who can be charged for the extra kill.
Strongman makes no sense in a setup that has a superconditional doc and nothing else. Yet it's likely that we did actually see a strongman kill tonight.
I don't know. When I was reading stuff during the night I was looking forward to getting a result on Prims, especially since ANOTHER framer/etcetera had just died. Shadoweh addresses Serela like it's not on her mind at all.
That reminds me though, I don't really want Conq to die, and killing him seems like the next logical step if you're going to protect Rou. You should split your decision between the two. Flip a coin or something.
Serela rightfully answers "what the fudge why should I risk losing that result" and Shadoweh's response is something about a slow cop being roughly the same as a confirmed townie? On what planet? It doesn't make sense that she'd read the situation like this unless she knew Rou wouldn't be a big factor.
Prims is Not Scum With Shadoweh due to that one D3 interaction. I'm pretty sure I'm reading the map correctly in that Shadoweh DID want to survive D3 through VCA and angrytone (and BBM's "waiting for Shadoweh to stay stuff" supports this) so the reaction to Prims probably wouldn't have been as strong if she was being bussed by her buddies. At least I'd like to think so. It could have been part of it and the only reason I'm entertaining this possibility so much is that Prims' vote on me today is trash - not only was Disgaea ages ago, it's a bad comparison altogether and if he thought my activity yesterday was suspect he didn't have to wait until now to say it.
The paragraph that goes here is literally a complete repeat of what Dan said about SB. like I literally typed it and looked over Dan's post again and it was literally repeating each and every point. Strongman + Dan/BBM connection. If SB is scum I don't mind being lynched afterwards considering we probably wouldn't need more than one mistake at that point. If SB ISN'T scum it's a much bigger problem and that's probably what I'd like to affirm is not the case for the majority of today day if everyone is just going to gravitate towards that.
YES THIS IS THE SHORT VERSION.
