I didn't suspect Shadoweh as being the final scum ... pretty much until after I had read edibles admission that she was a second time (It didn't register the first time). She did a fairly good job of covering her tracks and seem like the cute Town Belle that she usually is. The Nightkill caught me off guard, and my first thought was scum actually switched their kill to UK just because of my story. I pretty much wouldn't have even picked up on it myself until shadoweh hammered day five. That was pretty much the point where Shadoweh gave up all pretenses of being a pro-town player. If anyone who was in Lylo in this same situation with her and the Lurk Belle and actually voted Kitten4u, I would have questioned their ability to obtain and evaluate facts placed in front of them. Of course, this just means Omba is smart.
As for my own play, I'm very satisfied with it, even though I didn't get to do much. I tested out a new style of PBPA. Rather than listing everyone's own posts under their name, I instead listed all of the posts other people made that talked about them. It actually makes it a lot easier to see how the cases on people flow, and how the people on those cases move around. Like, for example, early day one, Dormio and Sect both wanted Shadoweh dead and gone until suddenly they didn't, and both switched away to two different town cases. In retrospect, this probably should have alerted me that they didn't really want Shadoweh dead.
My main problem however is that I tend to just lose interest and pester off the longer I spend being a part of the game, so of course I'm going to shine at my best when 1. I'm only alive for one day, and 2. That day is not day one.