As promised.
As an aside, oh hey, I was right, K4U was town.
I'll be honest here. I am going to ignore most of UD and Rou's posts. They are pretty much town despite their...interesting ideas of scumhunting. This will also make the read significantly easier on you all since I won't have to rehash what I've said tons of times.
And apparently I lied
Rou, is there any explanation you can share for
this?
(As an aside
this from me is horribly ironic given the tunneling I ended up getting from Rou)
I'll admit,
this from Zak is a little weird. It was mentioned then but exposing the supposed reaction fishing when 5 people were posting...out of 17, doesn't seem like a good idea.
Cha's subsequent response pointing this out does make it slightly less suspect.
Hey, first rather notable
post of the game, from Sodium. I already said my piece on it, but I'll say it again. It's still terrible, hypocritical, and reporter style.
Hmm...something somewhat notable
UsuallyDead: (7):
UncertainKitten
Edible: DayvigCarthrat
Arashi Kurobara
NietzChaoreKanakoOut of all remaining, does anyone think there's another scum? I...want to think so given the speed of the wagon, but I did just reread UD's behavior and am like "yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeah"
this post makes K4U look amazing.
Despite being right about Kana,
this post is again as terrible as the last time I read it. Same reasons.
this post bugs me. It reads to me like a summary, with a protection of Chaore and then a shift to Kanako. Of course, I did some similar stuff, didn't I? Difference being this was Serpentarius' first post of the game. I'm not sure I like this at all
this feels like a summary from Jam...but it's somewhat more expected from someone who's new. That said, it was a contributing factor to Cha's case.
Rereading
this, it feels like a protection of Sodium. contrasted with the Kanako attack, I'm
not getting good vibes from either Serpy or Sody.
this post is curious. I...well, it's a lot of words and "lol you all suck", but I don't see much analysis except effectively a throwaway vote on Pesco. I don't know how to read this, to be honest. It seems to be "Well, UK might be scum...well, one of UD and UK is scum. UD could be scum UD rage quitting."
What. is. your. stance?
Rereading
this, Keri misunderstood. I was assuming UD town and analyzing the bandwagon without his flip. I don't see myself tying myself to his flip in any proximity to your post.
As I said before,
this was the first semi decent post out of Sodium.
Another effective throwaway vote from Tom. Granted, it DID have some good points in it.
This from Sodium reads badly. It's some summary, some clearing of people who have flipped town, some poking a hornets nest but running away. Why did you say that about Carth if you weren't planning to follow up?
This post looks amazingly worse in retrospect, much for the same reasons some of mine do, except Serpy is saying Cha won't flip scum, whereas I had him second on my list.
The "How to falseclaim 101 by Serpent Tarius" post has already been belabored.
this feels a lot like "please, shut Cha up before he screws us up more." Is the us town or scum, I wonder? Given my inability to really read him before, this strikes me as scummy.
this is more Nietz tunnel from ET. Then again, he kinda needs to at this point.
Did I miss a page? Jam has 5 posts at this point? Yeesh. She definitely needs to be more out there.
The key issue here is that while Serpentarius is suspicious for trying to start a secondary wagon on a sitting duck target late in the day when the primary wagon is a Scum wagon, on the other hand Kanako is being terrible, providing garbage posts with no content, and always making excuses with promises for actual content later that never winds up manifesting itsself. I'm fairly certain that one of these is Scum, and that they're not BOTH Scum, but I'm not sure which of them is the Scum at the moment. Nietz is higher-priority right now anyway for me.
Checkmate. I have been drawing the same conclusion myself at this point. Well, except for the Nietz thing, though granted I found him scummy D2.
Ok, here's the thing about the quickly building Nietz wagon. So far everyone has good reasons for it, before we get to K4U's actually decent case on me.
this is terrible from the first line. Bragging much? Dear God, why the hell would you ever point out the Pesco NK like that? Considering the rest of it is more summary, it does not look good.
this post bothers me slightly. Why point out Nietz doing this and not EvilTom?
The most notable thing about
this post is the vote for Rou. It's understandable but also somewhat unforgiveable given the circumstances. She has good points, but the evidence points to dumb town on both parts.
this post, while better then most previous posts, has one problem. Where's Sodium in it? Where are a lot of players, but definitely sodium.
this feels well reasoned on Nietz. Makes me feel slightly better about ET but...I still don't like the "quick, shut him up" that came accross wrt Cha, and the throwaway votes.
Zak doesn't really seem to post much, the few times he does post. Not sure I like that.
I think I'm done
K4U, Carthrat, Edible and probably Alice and Rou are town
Serpy, Sodium, and possibly Zak and/or EvilTom are scum
No strong reads on other players. Jam should post more original content. Arashi is kinda there, but she has been posting.
Keri needs to post more.
All that said,
##Vote SerpentariusI have a present for all you who read all that stuff:
Everyone asking to be replaced can kiss my ass. I hate replacements.
Let's go, Mr. Zeppy.
##Geisterwand: Kanako
We had better lynch Nietz after this.
