I've always seen handwaving valid arguments - specifically, attacking the person or the argument with lines like "thats stupid" and not tackling the meat of the logical issue as a big scumtell. Both Polaris and Dormio had done that to Mitsuki who had posted what I thought was an exceptional piece. So that was what elevated both of them to scumlevel for me.
Mitsuki's argument against Polaris made no sense, therefore it was stupid.
It wasn't logical and it wasn't worth my time bothering to pick apart.
And you realize that it's entirely possible to read people as town without agreeing with whatever it is they're saying or even thinking that they're on the completely wrong path.
Remember, nobody on town has any fucking clue about the alignments of anyone else (other than cops) so their guess is as good as yours and not necessarily right just because they're town.
Anyway, the reason I pipped Dormio over Polaris was because of his potty mouth.
lol?
That's a pretty terrible reason.
You are not going to have a good time playing with me if you're offended by swearing because it's something I do quite frequently.
I mean, Dormio, given that I was adamant about lynching you regardless the next day, who would you have nighhit? NNR or I? I think that if you were scum you would have gone for NNR because there was still some chance I would mislynch, whereas NNR would have DEFINITELY lynched if he got off his check on you.
You realize that this question makes no fucking sense?
If I were town, then I can't kill and therefore cannot choose to kill either of NNR or you.
However, lets say that we were in the opposite situation where I am town and Polly-kun were scum and you have a "definite" scumread on Polly-kun, NNR would still die because NNR would be confirming me as town which leaves Polly-scum by PoE.
Like, seriously, your "gambit" to get yourself killed over NNR would never work.