just posting some thoughts since i guess my opinions aren't actually that clear at this point
5. PX
unimpressed with px having all of one serious post despite telling us whenever he's off work. if you won't have much time to post in mafia then you use what you little have wisely. shadoweh case doesn't look like he was trying to convince other people so much as just have a suspect; basically more and more comfortable with this lynch as he stays AFK
13. Serela
past few posts are townier but he needed 3 votes and an easy target to jump on before he could produce. don't like "CONSOLIDATION IS GOOD" * leaves vote parked on ihnn * either. still bad but i don't like my company on his wagon and too many people think he's town!serela to consolidate so he goes free today i guess
8. Drrawr
reads the same way he did when he was my scumbuddy in that one game; he's going after people who are already targets and doesn't care much about his own case on affinity. good lynch, nothing to say that hasn't already been said because there's so little to talk about here
12. Hero999
is a lot worse after his recent content, aside from the cute dux. posting a list of every player in the game with zero-analysis one line opinions on them is the epitome of active lurking. can't even tell if he still wants serela lynched or not since he struck out his rawr vote and hasn't been talking about it. i see him asking a lot of questions without trying to find the answers and scumhunt himself, and i'd lynch him for that
1. Bardiche / Dorian
still find bard's ed1 post scummy, and have a nitpick with dorian:
I would be only too willing to go with HWs lurckscum case if he were not such a complete shot into the dark.
seriously? px is lurking and not scumhunting and he's a good lynch to you, but when rawr plays similarly he's a "shot in the dark"? ??? this is a weird-ass double standard
otherwise dorian hasn't posted anything flagrantly bad but i got my eye on you
6. Ihavenoname
if he's town then he needs to stop mentioning how he needs to look at people then barely saying anything about them until it's not relevant. the way he's trying to look into people and interactions makes me think his play is more "weak town" than "scum" though, i don't really see him pushing mislynches or anything. actually better than most people on this list
everyone else ranges from Just OK to Town and i basically agree that firebombing the scummiest active lurkers is likely to find scum this game. not sure what to think about affinity anymore, recent posts have been solid and i don't have anything on him but i could see him as scum anyway. reads like affinity i guess
i would probably swap hero and ihnn on conq's list though. ihnn looks like he's scumhunting only not very thoroughly while hero looks like he's hunting for weird things to point out and not scum and this is worse imo