A lot of noise from UD and UK. UD at the start looks like a townie being brash just because he can but that gradually erodes into a more likely Refuge in Audacity (no TVTropes link for you), provoking and tunneling in UK, getting his arguments all over the place and back again, and when other players begin to call him on it, his answer is to ignore them in favor of more UK tunneling.
UK's anger and frustration seem genuine enough, and jumping on a newb town and trying to bring him to lynch from early day 1 is not a sound tactic for experienced scum.
Chaore had some discussions and generally looked active, but in the end there was pretty much nothing coming out of it. Said that we should focus on the "dangerous" instead of UK (implying, I suppose, that if she's scum she'll be easily caught later). There isn't any correlation in the "danger" of a player and the likelihood of him getting a scum role and this is just likely to induce judgement bias, but even when pressed for opinions on scum he gave none.
Pesco looks alright, asking questions that needed to be asked and stuff.
Zakeri, if he's scum, I can see the point of defending town-UD, since he will be very likely lynched, if not Day 1 at some later point. I did agree with his thinking at that point in the thread though, so I'd rather wait to see how his stances develop.
I'm between UD and Chaore, but UD is the worst offender, and I seriously think he will get himslef lynched lynched sooner or later anyway.
##Vote UD
