Yume Nikki Mafia - Over

[FinnKaenbyou]

Okay, yeah, scratch what I said earlier. Serp is obvMVP.

[Serp]

Town had many good players, but I think that Serp was particularly good at playing Cop. Early game had everyone pointing out how pro-town and confirmed he was, so at that point he probably saw an NK coming his way and started acting a little more scummy for safety. His Edible clear on day 2 probably felt scummy as well, but would have been a very clear breadcrumb in case he was killed. I was only disappointed that he didn't suspect his results on Zakeri on day 3.

I think I overdid it a little.  Playing purposefully scummy is an extremely fine line to tread, as BaitySM could tell you.  By mid-Day 1, I was questionable enough that the scum wouldn't want to waste a kill on me, but I came close to getting lynched myself as well.  If I, the cop, had been the third lynch instead of the mafia godfather Pesco, I'd be the complete opposite of Town MVP, I think.  I was also sincerely surprised at Pesco's and SP's flips, and probably would've gone after Carthrat on Day 3 if Edible and Zakeri hadn't both recommended umu.

Anyway, very cool setup.  I wish we had gotten a chance to play in more rooms.

[LHCling]

What? Over already?

I think I overdid it a little.  Playing purposefully scummy is an extremely fine line to tread, as BaitySM could tell you.

Yep.

Of course, it would be hard to tell what would happen if I didn't throw myself out like that...  >_>

...reading through D2, I would say that was a rather chaotic "turnabout" (if that's the right word for it).

Maybe I should lurk these games some more, and analyze player data, since some of you seem to utilize it as such for your arguments. Actually, it's better if I don't, since not watching games removes player bias from my arguments.

[?q]

FTR I don't think Baity played that badly in this game; the Town just had no idea how to read him and decided to off him... which in this game turned out to be quite acceptable.

[Kanako Yasaka]

I, on the other hand, deserve honorary scum more than Baity does. Looking back at my posts is embarassing.

[WHMZakeri]

Just remember blender that if the town votes you for being too agressive, the town deserves a mislynch. Unless you're scum.

Actually, it's better if I don't, since not watching games removes player bias from my arguments.

That's a good idea, since using Meta as the basis for a case is almost as much of a scumtell as using WiFoM as the basis for a defense.

[?q]

That's a good idea, since using Meta as the basis for a case is almost as much of a scumtell as using WiFoM as the basis for a defense.

I disagree, as long as the meta is applied correctly.

[Edible]

Meta is good for supporting a case or for finding initial suspicion, but by itself it falls short almost every time.

[?q]

Meta is good for supporting a case or for finding initial suspicion, but by itself it falls short almost every time.

For convincing people, yes.
This is why I keep petitioning for more dayvigs.

[WHMZakeri]

You should have said so at the beginning. I'd have been happy to dole them out.

[Carthrat]

And get NK'd? >_>

[Jana]

But Zakeri's role made him un-NK-able.

So yeah.

[?q]

You

at the beginning

You lost me.

[Carthrat]

...seriously?

Man, he had no reason no to use that. Town would probably never lynch him...

[WHMZakeri]

And yet it was still the only chance I had at winning in a game that only had one mafioso playing at a time.