Ok, let's go back at it:
Rou: I came so strong on Anthony at the beginning of D2 that I soon more-or-less dismissed it as typical TownRou meta. He does keep playing consistently with that, but I don't think that's enough to clear him any more, considering VgT's flip.
Here is when he firsts acknowledges there is a VgT case, and says that he might vote him unless he does something "AWESOME", which I don' think he did, but instead he starts the wagon on Suwako, and his only further mentions of VgT are downplaying is suspicion value (by
88 he's down to sixth place in the scummy list), which is weird because the case on VgT wasn't that different from Anthony's to begin with. Also pretty much drops the case on Anthony, except for mentioning that
he's fine with either a Suwako or Antony lynch, when an Anthony lynch clearly wasn't going to happen anymore.
Also, I don't think he has answered to this:
I suppose the thing with Tenshi is that he seems almost too obvious. >_>
Then again, given that, Town!Tenshi would logically have been easy prey for scum yesterday, and since no-one went for him...
What? By what logic would scum go after an largely uncooperative town that's likely to be wagoned the next day. It wouldn't make sense even to avoid a protect, considering how many player there were left.
He said it even before Anthony said the same thing, but unlike Anthony he wasn't questioned for it.
And about Anthony and his new voteblock thing, I really didn't like how, instead of just asking the mod to correct the count, he made a huge scene of re-voting and voting yet again just to call everyone's attention to his situation. This really gives me the feel of a scumbuddy using such an ability on him as a ploy to make him look town. Admittedly, this theory fails if that's actually a Town power, or if scum is trying to WIFOM him, but I'm still confident in it, particularly considering Anthony's choice of "safe" target.
About Angel Milk, I really would prefer him modkilled, but not if that will carry a penalty to Town if he's a townie.
@Edible: Can you clarify that?
@Nietz
Personally I feel a kind of weird dynamic over Nietz's posts about Anthony and Angel Milk. On D1, Nietz did defend VgT and Anthony to some extent and was wary of scum voting them due to them being easy targets, which is the very basis of his pesco vote, but his recent post here on D2 more or less does the same thing with Angel Milk, except that he accentuates the negative, thinking that he's anti-town, and yet still wary of people voting him for that. Why?
Anti-town ≠ scummy. Both attitudes can lead to town voting someone, but the first is usually a better ground for scum to push a myslinch.
Also, how, in your view, do you differentiate a newbie bewildered by all these posts and posting bad content, to a newbie posting bad content more regularly? Their mistakes are mostly the same variety, so how is Angel Milk more scummy than Anthony in this regard?
What's was scummy about Milk was basically his only meaningful action being joining the Suwako wagon, the rest was pure anti-town inactivity. But he's not more scummy than Anthony, especially considering the latter's recent voteblock stunt.
Lastly, I don't particularly like how VgT's flip affects your view of playstyles and Anthony for this game, seeing that you supposedly had a larger body of evidence saying that newbies were often mislynches, this kind of makes you feel like some compulsive gambler. Gives an air of inconsistency about your playstyle which I don't really endorse; this is bad for the crops.
I don't think I understand your point here. I admit that I was wrong on judging VgT, so I might have been wrong about Anthony on the same grounds. Plus, his play is getting scummier as the game goes on, as I mentioned in
D1 already.
There's still some people I should read better, but right now I'm pretty much set on Anthony, Serp and Rou in order of suspicions. Anthony's voteblock drama put him ahead, though I would be fine with the others as well.
##Vote Anthony I have a statement I'd usually apply here but it comes off as bitchy so I'll spare it.
I miss the old UK.
