Polly~ Buddy~ You're going to be our tie breaker here, apparently. So who do you want to vote for most? (Try to avoid going into scumpair theories, even though that's the popular thing right now.)
@Rou: I admit that superbusing isn't really the term I should have used. It's true that you've not once voted for huhwhat. Even still, you've put the most effort into making and resulting the case on him, and voted Serela based on *-scumpair theories-* due to the unlikely nature of the huh-what lynch. Then, suddenly at the start of day 3, you decide to make a case on NeoSerela, and officially put Huhwhat second on your list, even though "Nothing has happened to change you opinion of huhwhat." The only thing that Neo did between your first post and your first post of day 3 was his own opening post of day 3, which you misrepped. It's not busing in a strict sense, but It does smell like distancing somehow. The thing about Lylo however is that scum can put whoever they want for their second to lynch as long as the first to lynch is a townie.
Also, since Rou's asking for it: My anti-case on NeoSerela.
This is in reference to Kimblee's 93~94. I don't see how you reached this conclusion, Affinity.
To sum it up, he says Affinity is lurky, he's on the fence about PX, and then Pesco/Serela look bad. Town read on Huhwhat and neutral on Nobu/Polly. His conclusions seem fairly clear, and a Fency/Lurky with two scummy reads doesn't sound like making everyone look scummy.
Serela brings up an interesting point, here. It's a shame he doesn't get the chance to see this through, since Affinity was nightkilled. I don't think Serela would have killed someone that he came up with an original basis of suspicion on. Especially since NeoSerela didn't have anything else prepared, which was apparent from his post 132 - a lurker prod.
Neoserela spends all of day 2 pressing his case on PX as PX grows more and more worse over the day. There was really no reason for anyone to move from the PX wagon yesterday, whether they were town or scum. In fact, moving away from PX would probably have been more scummy, since it would singal that they knew he was town. NeoSerela stays on him the whole days, and continues to believe he's scum with conviction.
Then, of course, there's the opinion misrep that Rou seems to still be trying to capitalize on.
The post that sells me the most on Serela's townieness is 168. NeoSerela starts by figuring out scum based on process of elimination (It's never a good idea to admit that, even if it's true.) Then he proceeds to attempt making a case, but talks himself into a circle. He started out by saying he knew it Rou and Huhwhat have to be scum together, then discards his case because it relies on the fact that he thinks Huhwhat and Rou are scum together. This then kind of spirals downward until he's confused. The thing is, Scum normally wouldn't be confused about who's scum and who's town, because they already know. The fact that he confused himself while trying to figure out who's scum reads to me that NeoSerela is town. Just that he doesn't have the knowledge or experience needed to know how to make a well-thought out argument.
Suddenly knowing that puts a gobstopper on the whole "NeoSerela is waffling" Argument. Anyone voting for NeoSerela at this point is trying to push a newbie case over a scum case
in lylo. With that, I'm content to believe Huhwhat and Rou are the pair we've been looking for.
##Vote: Huhwhat
