Finally got time to read through the quicktopic. Sorry Pesco, I was indeed busier, but only in spurts so I did manage to get stuff in during working hours (blame it on the economy). I think you guys reflected well on most of your mistakes in there and the planned mislynches looked good except for Rou's ability blowing through half of them quicker than you would have liked.
umu deserves some huge cred for nailing Zengar and Sodium correctly as Scum as well as saying KGH was probably Town. Very good stuff all by the mid of Day 1. For the amount of time he was able to play this game, I say he deserves MVP for getting those votes in first.
KGH: If you played it straight, there would have been far less doubt about you and your case on Pesco in Day 4 would have gotten more support instead of it being considered Too Little Too Late. Just look at that aspect of your game and you can see where you
up. Also, don't self hammer if you're Town with no minimum requirement for a lynch. If there happened to be other Scum out there, you have to make them vote for you for a particular reason which Town could analyze the following Day.
Sorry I had Kilga and UK popping veins for a bit. Not the optimal way for me to be playing Town, but with the early going relatively smooth, I figured we couldn't get complacent so I jacked up everyone's anxiety to keep everyone relevant and prepare for the worst case scenario (which we almost got to). But you guys were admittedly solid through the entire game and I was half trying to find chinks in that gameplay when there really weren't any even when I said that several times during the game. Chew me out a little if you feel that's a terrible way for me to play.
I still think the Alice lynch was a better case to pursue than the Pesco lynch Day 3 after I found that post Suwako made in Day 1 voting UK. Sorry Suwako/Alice. *shrug*
Lol Edible, you should have seen that double facepalm I did after Day 2 ended. I just leaned back in my chair and cried out, OH MY GOD!
That being said, kudos to Serp for getting 1 successful protect in. It gave me the clout to fool around a little like I mentioned above. But I'll try not to do that again next time. And we seriously missed that hint about your Doc role when you revoted Sodium after Edible's gambit. That was smooth and your reason was good too. Gotta store that one for future reference.
K4U: Well, you did tunnel a bit and you asked us to smack you if you were, but we didn't because we can't coach you on how to play during the game. It never hurts to look around early on as it's obvious there are multiple Scum targets around to be found. I've made mistakes with assuming Scum accidentally slip a word out, but I got burned on it before (PC-98 Mafia) so I never use it as a primary reason anymore.
Rou had his role to clear him, but hey, if you have a virtually unfakable, unblockable, and unambiguously Town role like that, I can't see how a little tunneling and going by your gut instincts doesn't hurt. It worked out for us though and you made the right call in shooting Pesco in the end.
