I'm... really not seeing anything actually good in Miyako's nightpost.
Mmk, what she says about the Steven wagon being MotK derptown lynch obsession is
partially true. This actually wasn't all that bad of a case for a derptown lynching. But yes, MotK likes to lynch derptown too much.
Saki covered the part about Shannon. I have absolutely no idea why Miyako is trying to make Shannon look bad for voting the wagon that isn't her so she survives. If she
didn't do that, I'd wonder if she was a Jester or something, and lets not even get into how I feel about Jester roles.
First paragraph about me is... kinda true I suppose, actually. I am agreeing with a lot of people without much explanation, most notably where it looks like I practically handwave Shannon as town. I do need to reread Shannon today to review her D2 actions.
For example, in this post she says a whole lot of opinions without actually saying who is scum.
So, I don't say who I think is scum, except... err, how about that sentence at the end where I say the three people I think might be scum?
Lastly, she progresses from saying Shannon as potential scum team material, to thinking that "case on Steven is good but I like Mason more because noobplay is town" and finally, voting Steven even though she defended him more than Shannon.
I didn't feel Shannon to be particularly scummy after her response post, as I said. My feelings on Steven were "This case isn't bad but could all just be derptown." I'd rather lynch someone I can't read then someone I don't feel to be scummy. And derptown is a liability in LyLo as I said, so it's not quite as bad as lynching some other townie.
She also has very little solid opinions, so despite her vote on Gamzee, I am willing to think her scum.
*waffle waffle waffle* :D
Anyway, Miyako wants to lynch Shannon to get insight on my alignment. With her having been the other wagon yesterday, I'd say it looks like she'll get her wish. I'll reread Shannon to see how I feel about her now.
Ninjaed by Miyako. Why are you still trying to make her look bad for voting Steven at deadline?
It goes against her 'voting on bad reasoning is bad' which she used to implicate easy targets; she should vote herself in that case
Except that's the best reason to vote someone ever, as Saki said. There is absolutely no reason someone should NOT vote the other person in this case, with the rare exception of knowing the other person is DEFINITELY town and will be MORE helpful to town (such as a power role), whixh is an extremely situational case.
In fact, the post you linked as an example DIRECTLY contradicts EXACTLY what you're blaming Shannon for! Here is the quote from said post.
3.) I find it inherently scummy to not be on one of the major wagons at the end of the day (with certain exceptions, such as not being there at the time). As I said above, a vote is also a way to be transparent. Even if you think both of the wagons are town, you must surely find one of them better than the other (whether that be for informational purposes, or whether you just find one person more likely to be scum than the other even if it's just by a small amount). Scum do not want their actions and opinions to be tracked easily, so I find it more likely that scum will be off both the wagons than town (these kinds of votes are usually referred to as "throwaway votes").
I think Miyako is trying a bit too hard to get reasons to push the Shannon case, as the reasons she brought up tonight are both nulltells and directly contradicted by
the very example of them she linked; I'm starting to like the idea of a Shannon lynch today too, as if Shannon flips town, I'm
really not going to be liking Miyako very much.
I'm going to hold off on voting Shannon right away until I do my reread, however. If I think Shannon looks pretty town I might just go right to Miyako instead.
